Brain's 'trust machinery' identified

By SullyGuy · Apr 24, 2009 · Updated Apr 29, 2009 · ·
  1. SullyGuy
    Brain's 'trust machinery' identified

    The brain centers triggered by a betrayal of trust have been identified by researchers, who found they could suppress such triggering and maintain trust by administering the brain chemical oxytocin. The researchers said their findings not only offer basic insights into the neural machinery underlying trust; the results may also help in understanding the neural basis of social disorders such as phobias and autism.

    Thomas Baumgartner and colleagues published their findings in the May 22, 2008, issue of the journal Neuron, published by Cell Press.
    In their experiments, the researchers asked volunteer subjects to play two types of games—a trust game and a risk game. In the trust game, subjects were asked to contribute money, with the understanding that a human trustee would invest the money and decide whether to return the profits, or betray the subjects’ trust and keep all the money. In the risk game, the subjects were told that a computer would randomly decide whether their money would be repaid or not.
    The subjects also received doses of either the brain chemical oxytocin (OT) or a placebo via nasal spray. They chose OT because studies by other researchers had shown that OT specifically increases people’s willingness to trust others.
    During the games, the subjects’ brains were scanned using functional magnetic resonance imaging. This common analytical technique involves using harmless magnetic fields and radio waves to map blood flow in brain regions, which reflects brain activity.
    The researchers found that—in the trust game, but not the risk game—OT reduced activity in two brain regions: the amygdala, which processes fear, danger and possibly risk of social betrayal; and an area of the striatum, part of the circuitry that guides and adjusts future behavior based on reward feedback.
    Baumgartner and colleagues concluded that their findings showed that oxytocin affected the subjects’ responses specifically related to trust.
    “If subjects face the nonsocial risks in the risk game, OT does not affect their behavioral responses to the feedback. Both subjects in the OT group and the placebo group do not change their willingness to take risks after the feedback. In contrast, if subjects face social risks, such as in the trust game, those who received placebo respond to the feedback with a decrease in trusting behavior while subjects with OT demonstrate no change in their trusting behavior although they were informed that their interaction partners did not honor their trust in roughly 50% of the cases.”
    The researchers also wrote that “our insights into the neural circuitry of trust adaptation, and oxytocin’s role in trust adaptation, may also contribute to a deeper understanding of mental disorders such as social phobia or autism that are associated with social deficits. In particular, social phobia (which is the third most common mental health disorder) is characterized by persistent fear and avoidance of social interactions.”
    Rutgers University psychologist Mauricio Delgado, in a preview in the same issue of Neuron, wrote that the paper “represents an ambitious and informative development in the literature,” He commented that the study “has significant implications for understanding mental disorders where deficits in social behavior are observed. Betrayal aversion, for example, could serve as a precursor to social phobia, a disorder characterized by aversion to social interactions, with the reported oxytocin finding providing a bridge for potential clinical applications.”
    The researchers include Thomas Baumgartner, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland; Markus Heinrichs, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland; Aline Vonlanthen, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland; Urs Fischbacher, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland; and Ernst Fehr, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland, Collegium Helveticum, Zurich, Switzerland.


    Another article.

    Share This Article


  1. sandoz1943
    Great article! Oxytocin is also released during labor and premotes birth and breast feeding. As a mom who was very pro breast I wonder if more woman embraced breast feeding we might have more well adjusted adults latter on down the road.
  2. Ilsa
    indeed, nice find! oxytocin and vasopressin are both important bonding/social hormones, and imho (even though i'm not a parent, i've read a little lit here and there) mothers who breas-feed are probably significantly enhancing the efficiency with which they bond with their child. so, yes sandoz, i think there's something to that....mother's milk actually provides immunoprotection to the infant throughout the time before weaning, until the infant's immune system begins developing.

    oxytocin is also released during orgasm, helping partners bond via sex (although i don't think it counts for drunken one night stands :laugh:). just an interesting factoid from the recesses of my brain that still retain some neuro knowledge.
  3. sandoz1943
    Great I will tell my man this and see if it works. But baby it will make us closer. Realy it will. God I am such the guy in my marriage. I cant understand why women who can breast feed dont. Special baby and mommy time. Just the two of you. Who would want to pass that up?
  4. kaczynski
    I'm a little worried they'll start doling this out to everyone with a social phobia. A large group of people might become a little too trusting of their governments.
  5. chillinwill
    Thanks for posting SullyGuy.

    Please note that the way we post news has changed, because of our main news page. You can find the full instructions here.

    The most important changes are:

    • Articles are no longer posted in quotes.
    • The introduction of the article should be in bold.
    • Images should be added if possible and placed in the article, following the instructions linked to above and here.
    • Information about the article, like link, author, date should be posted below the article.
    • Your personal comments about the article can be posted either in quotes at the end of the article or in a separate post.
    • The news forums may contain news articles only
    • Make sure you include all the text from the original article. Don't just post the URL because web pages often disappear or get moved over time. Remove all unnecessary formatting from the text before posting. One easy way to do this is to paste the text into notepad or another text editor first, which will remove any formatting. Also try to remove picture captions, advertisement links and other text that doesn't belong to the body of the article.

    Please be so kind to review your articles and correct this.

    Further it may be good to know that recent articles with the highest thread ratings show up on the main news page. So without ratings, many people will not see it. So please rate news treads.
    The main news page is accessible from the tabs on the top of any DF page.
  6. nibble
    And is of course hypothesized to be released on administration of MDMA.
    Fascinating and powerful little chemical..
  7. Alfa
    High levels of oxytocin are released after 4-MTA intake. 4-MTA can cause a feeling of everything being special. FUBAR remembers that his trust and confidence was high when under the influence of 4-MTA.
  8. SullyGuy
    @chillin: Is it better now? And apologies, I will follow those guidelines from now on when posting articles.
  9. chillinwill
    Yes indeed it is. Thanks for changing that.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!