1. Dear Drugs-Forum readers: We are a small non-profit that runs one of the most read drug information & addiction help websites in the world. We serve over 4 million readers per month, and have costs like all popular websites: servers, hosting, licenses and software. To protect our independence we do not run ads. We take no government funds. We run on donations which average $25. If everyone reading this would donate $5 then this fund raiser would be done in an hour. If Drugs-Forum is useful to you, take one minute to keep it online another year by donating whatever you can today. Donations are currently not sufficient to pay our bills and keep the site up. Your help is most welcome. Thank you.
  1. chillinwill
    As I stood with a rolled up bank note in my hand, staring down at the thin line of white powder I was about to snort, I thought back to the innocent shopping trip earlier that day which had led to all this.

    I should emphasise now that taking drugs does not constitute my usual type of weekend activity, I assure you. I am, after all a doctor and, having seen first hand the devastation that illegal drugs cause, I'd never advocate their use.

    The drug I was about to do, though, wasn't illegal. I'd broken no law when I bought it and I wasn't breaking any by taking it.

    Yet, this controversial substance is now the drug of choice for many young people in the UK.

    I had been in central London buying a birthday card when I noticed a row of small packets on the counter by the till. They caught my eye and as I waited to pay I absentmindedly picked one of them up. On the inside was stapled a small transparent bag with a white powder inside. In tiny letters on the front it said: 'water soluble all purpose plant feed'.


    For a brief moment I was genuinely puzzled as to why a gift shop was selling plant food.

    Then I suddenly realised, this wasn't plant food in the conventional, Baby Bio, sense. This was mephedrone, sometimes known as "meow meow" or "plant food".

    It's not to be confused with methadone - a heroin substitute, which is a carefully controlled, prescription-only medication.

    Instead, it's a "legal high" that has become increasingly popular as a cheap and easy alternative to illegal street drugs such as ecstasy or cocaine.

    I first heard about the drug last summer. At first, it was patients who incidentally reported taking it when I was seeing them in A&E and I asked about their drug use.

    They all raved about it. And here, standing in a shop just a few hundred yards from London's Oxford Street on a crisp, spring afternoon, I'd stumbled across it for myself.

    Impulsively I bought some. Back at home, I debated whether I should actually try it. Surely it can't be that bad if I can buy it in a shop, I reasoned to myself. But more than anything I felt I had to know what it was that so many of my patients were telling me they were taking each weekend and whose experiences were in such stark contrast to the media scare stories.

    I reasoned that by trying it I might understand better the drug's appeal and decide for myself if the government is right in pushing ahead to make it illegal. My prohibition on taking drugs up until this point had been that they were illegal.

    I think that people should be free to make choices about their lives and that, providing they are aware of the consequences, this includes doing things that might damage their health. I am not a complete puritan - I smoke and drink.

    But my problem with illegal drugs is the human suffering that surrounds this market. They ruin lives and communities and that's not something I want to buy into.

    But this was different. There was a veneer of respectability about buying this drug and it was this, along with the complete ease with which I obtained it, that worried me afterwards. I didn't need a dealer or contacts. I'd wandered into a shop and picked it up as though it were a pair of novelty socks. This drug isn't even like alcohol or cigarettes, which have age restrictions on their use. Literally anyone can get hold of it and yet it is so new we know next to nothing about its long-term effects.

    What particularly worries me is protecting the young, because their concept of risk is still developing and their ability to moderate their use of substances is often poor. It's ludicrous that teenagers who the law says cannot even buy a goldfish are able to obtain this stuff perfectly legally and that parents and schools have no official powers to intercede. Something does have to be done.

    For a multitude of reasons, people like to use intoxicants. What is becoming increasingly apparent is that for some, the main legally sanctioned one - alcohol - is not adequate. Alcohol is a depressant and there are groups of people who want to use a stimulant instead. While this market exists, they will either use illegal drugs like ecstasy or cocaine, or seek 'legal' alternatives, which have the added bonus of being cheaper and purer and not carrying the risk of imprisonment.

    Making mephedrone illegal will stop many of the people I know using it. It will also remove the implicit suggestion that because it's legal it must be safe and will stop it being so readily available to teenagers.

    But I also know that simply making something illegal will not stop it being used by everyone, or indeed eradicate the need that people have to take substances that temporarily alter their experience of the world and intoxicate them.

    I do not take drug use lightly. But if we want to ensure that people are kept as safe as possible, then is banning it the best solution?

    As yet another expert - Eric Carlin - resigns from the government drugs advisory board amid claims that not enough is being done to actually help those using drugs and reduce harm particularly to young people, do our current policies on tackling drug use really work?

    The reality is that, as soon as mephedrone is banned, it's only a matter of time before another substance will take its place. Then what?

    After yet more tragic deaths, yet more legislation will be rushed through and this new substance will be banned and the whole sorry fiasco will start again.

    The rise of the internet has meant that it is all too easy to take a basic chemical structure, make a few alterations, email the formula off to an overseas laboratory and, in no time, a new drug is born. The authorities will always be one step behind.

    There may come a point in the future where we tire of this cat-andmouse game and accept there is a need for a legally sanctioned stimulant.

    Perhaps it will be safer in the long term to restrict the use of these substances to adults and license their sale and enable information to be gathered about their side effects, longterm health implications, dosing and risk minimisation, just as we have done with alcohol and cigarettes.


    It will mean that people aren't pushed into breaking the law, that quality can be ensured and perhaps even sales of other, illegal drugs, will fall, just as has happened with ecstasy and cocaine since mephedrone became available.

    It will also quash the drive for creating new legal highs which minors can get their hands on.

    While ministers like to appear to be tough on drugs and to respond quickly to public concerns, perhaps what is needed if we're going to ensure that people's health is best protected is to step back and think carefully.

    I can understand now why people might be attracted to mephedrone - I felt euphoric, energised and elated after I took it.

    But I can equally understand the concerns that the drug attracts. In an ideal world people wouldn't feel the need to use drugs to enjoy themselves, but we have to be practical because people's lives are at stake.

    We desperately need a sensible, adult debate about this, because my concern is that knee-jerk reactions won't actually solve the problem.

    They might even make it worse.

    25 The number of deaths linked to mephedrone in England and Wales. A recent drugs poll showed 41.7% of clubbers had taken it

    £4-£30 The cost of 1g of mephedrone. The average profit margin on 1kg imported from China if sold at £10 a gram is £7,500

    By Max Pemberton
    April 5, 2010


  1. godztear
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    Good read, very well written. Although it would have been nice if he showed how many deaths were related to a couple other drugs in England and Wales to make a comparison. SWIM would have if the numbers were as he imagines them to be.
  2. BlackHelicopters
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    25 deaths... and you want a legally sanctioned stimulant? Drink some coffee. just because something is legal doesn't make it good for you, especially when the only reason it's illegal is because no one came upon that chemical equation before this whole thing. And alot more people's lives would be at stake if we had something as abusable as this shit.
  3. Tamis
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    Mephedrone is responsible of one death for sure in 2008 !
    Only one death (no data available regarding dosage or any other details, (remember even water (a certain number of liters in an hour) kills.... as to the 24 others, no medical exams could prove mepehdrone to be the sole responsible (because of multiple products abused)... or death even had natural causes, who forgot this young girl whose parents did all they could to get mephedrone banned ? autopsy DEFINATLY showed a pneumonia killed her and that mephedrone hade nothing to do with it !! No Products are dangerous to the educated man... So come on members of the governement, please educate the people that voted for you, but do not force them to obeydiance because it is unavoidable that one day... I, We, US the people, we will react and we're going to be BADLY PISSED regarding the cruel lack of respect you have for us - for the people - for US the humankind !!

    YES ! Mephedrone can kill... so can peanuts or even water...
    NO ! It should never have been banned (I did initially vote that it should on DF poll)... seeing the VERY wild dosage and frequency of use of some users, we can clearly state it is a very forgiving drug (a LOT aren't... those already are on the market and streets as you read this) !

    We should have read about tens of thousands of death (at the VERY least) worldwide !! We should have stories/reports about hundreds of thousands users right here on DF telling about famillies broken by death, madness and so on ! As a matter in fact lots of DF posters are allready blowing the whistle but on other "legal high" (and THEY definatly KNOW what they are talking about) !! Experts appointed by the governement were against the ban and were not listened to... several quitted !! All this at the same and FOR the first time under the eyes of all european residents that care to read the news !

    So COME ON PEOPLE open you eyes -> Don't YOU SEE IT COMING ??!!

    Internet is about to render useless the world's stupid prohibition people, simply because the new rc that are coming as replacement are FAR worse than mephedrone showed to be. This won't go unnoticed when people start getting truly hurt this time by the next gen of RC and that the death counts become terribly frightening !

    I can see mothers interviewed on newspapers and tv saying "This new drug killed my son with just 10mg... that would never have happened with mephedrone !! I preparing with my lawyer to sue whoever is responsible of this nonsense that led to poison being available at ridiculous prices to our children".

    mephdrone : 1g = 4 to 10 doses per gram - quite ineffective redosing compared to mdma or coke
    naphyrone or mdpv (first examples that come to my minnd) : 1g = 200 doses - very effective redosing - many psychotic states reported without ANY prior warning signs. Ban those again (like if history proved prohibition worked...) AND WORSE WILL FOLLOW and so on..... this just plainly can't go on for long !

    So wait and watch ... a few months (at worse a few years...) will do !

    Just all stand up and yell : "Enough ! we, the people, want our freedom back and there is no stopping us !". Get this straight, they (politicians, governements, etc) can barely stop a few of us, they definatly cannot stop humankind.

    We the human kind LIKE taking drugs, this is a fact from the beginning of recorded history ! No politicians or laws can/could change and/or avoid this absolute fact that we like using drugs (without being suicidal), neither in the past (epic failure all the way) nor in the future (we won't let you guys trust me).

    It looks like the time to make sure drugs users (you, me, us, swim, swiy, mankind...) are ALL safe and unpunished is NOT that far away !! We are just plain NORMAL citizens and want to be respected and treated as such !! It is our right to be free and to be respected, let's not forget this :)

    This is just so close to happening and cannot be stopped now, how could it ?! This is my humble opinion (i'm rarely wrong though) !

    Peace.... LOVE !
  4. socialresearchuk
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    Making Mephedrone illegal will do three main things:
    1. It will reduce the number of users.
    2. It will criminalise those who still take it, and will make those who used to take it appear criminal.
    3. It will make people go for illegal alternatives - this has been seen to be oh too true in the East Midlands.
  5. girlygrrl
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    Recreational drugs should be regulated for safety, but not criminalized.

    Of what benefit is it to society to lock people up for personal drug use? The answer to ending deaths is EDUCATION not CRIMINALIZATION.

    Now those who enjoy the substance will buy from street dealers who cut the product and charge them considerably more money. If one was addicted to this substance, suddenly their addiction could fuel criminal behavior and/or prevent them from seeking the help they need out of fear of legal ramifications.

    Prohibition is a lazy answer. It may reduce the initial popularity and ease of access to a drug but it will not eliminate its use. It's just a political excuse to please paranoid parents.
  6. Lithium Aluminum Hydride
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    That is exactly what swim, and many other drug users, think. But then, swim remembers that laws are modeled to fit the interests of the powerful people at the governments and big corporations, and so swim loses his hope in that such a change would ever be possible.

    Anyway, legality is just arbitrary, a drug should not be considered safe just because it's legal and neither a drug should be considered a "poison" just for being illegal. There are deep dark interests behind legality.
  7. BlackHelicopters
    Re: Meow is legal so I tried it. But will banning every new drug really fix drug prob

    legalizing it won't decrease use regardless what you say. drugs are meant to be taken illegally people aren't ready for substance to be legal because obviously they can't control themselves, so if you choose to abuse there should be a risk involving the law. people can't handle their alcohol and you think they'll handle their mephedrone LOL hopefully it never happens. getting drugs illegally is the onlyway because its not something that should be openly part of society, for everyone's good.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!