Rate alcohol and tobacco like illegal drugs, says top scientist

By Synesthesiac · Nov 26, 2008 · Updated Nov 26, 2008 · ·
  1. Synesthesiac
    Rate alcohol and tobacco like illegal drugs, says top scientist


    Out of control: Professor Sir Gabriel Horn says alcohol is the most harmful recreational drug (posed by models)

    The harm done by tobacco and alcohol should be rated on the same system as illegal drugs, a leading scientist said today.
    Professor Sir Gabriel Horn who chaired a special committee on drug use, warned that dependency on drink and cigarettes was spiralling out of control and urgent measures were needed to curb their misuse.
    Professor Horn told the Government's drug advisors in London that many people believe alcohol is more harmful than heroin or cocaine.
    He told the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs: 'It's been recognised that [alcohol] is the most harmful recreational drug you could use. The risks are very similar to illegal substances.

    'Alcohol and tobacco highjack the same part of the brain [as illegal drugs]. This statutory body could be used as a really efficient conduit to prevent misuse. We must do something about this appalling burden to the nation. How long have we known about the dangers of tobacco smoke? But it took the Government a long time to take action and issue warnings. It's dangerous stuff.'

    Illegal drugs are regulated according to a classification system from A to C relating to the harm and risks involved in taking them. One possible new system would be for alcohol and nicotine to be ranked alongside them without being banned.

    Smoking dangers: Professor Horn warns that tobacco 'hijacks' the same part of the brain as illegal drugs.

    In the UK the total burden of alcohol misuse in terms of crime and antisocial behaviour is estimated at more than £12 billion a year. Professor Horn, who chaired the Academy of Medical Science's working group on drugs, also called for a special independent committee to be set up which would take the final decision on what ratings individual drugs should be given. This follows controversy over Prime Minister Gordon Brown's move to reinstate cannabis earlier this year as a class B drug. He overruled advice from the ACMD that there was not enough evidence to support such a move.

    The Lords is debating the drug's reclassification today. Professor Horn said a new independent classification committee could act in a similar way to the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of England which decides on interest rates independently of government. Ministers would be barred from choosing committee members, who would be appointed by academic bodies including the Royal Society and the AMS. Professor Horn told the ACMD: 'In my opinion, Parliament should devolve its responsibility on classification to an independent committee. Parliament would have to accept the decision of this classification committee.'

    Source: Daily mail UK http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/a...obacco-like-illegal-drugs-says-scientist.html

    By Daily Mail Reporter
    Last updated at 5:03 PM on 25th November 2008

    Share This Article


  1. dyingtomorrow
    Alcohol and tobacco are more harmful than MOST illegal drugs. They should either be illegalized (so people will wake the fuck up and legalize all drugs), or all other drugs should be legalized to save some time. The hypocracy and total lack of logic undermines faith in the government for a HUGE portion of the population.
  2. Heretic.Ape.
    Considering the classification of illegal drugs has almost no meaning regarding their safety I fail to see how this makes sense.
  3. tryptamaster
    yea, basically the legality of drugs has very very little to do with thier true danger and much more about politics economics and beurocracy.
  4. Expat98
    Please note that the way we post news articles has changed because of our main news page. You can find the full instructions here.

    The most important changes are:

    • Articles should be posted within the appropriate sub-forum (Health, Politics, Culture, etc.)
    • Articles should not be posted in quotes.
    • The introduction of the article should be highlighted in bold text. (Do not use oversized fonts as you have done here.)
    • Images should be added if possible and placed in the article, following the instructions linked to above and here.
    • Information about the article, such as link, author, and publication date should be posted below the article.
    • Your personal comments about the article can be posted below the article. (Please clearly mark the separation between the article and your comments.)
    • Only news articles should be posted in the news forums.

    Please be so kind to review your articles and correct this.

    Also it may be good to know that recent articles with the highest thread ratings show up on the main news page. So without ratings, many people will not see it. So please rate news threads.

    The main news page is accessible from the "News" tab on the top of any DF page.

  5. Nature Boy
    I was thinking the exact same thing. As a scare measure maybe, although it doesn't seem like a terribly effective strategy. It just sounds like an attempt to label something in hopes that people will shy away from it, but let's get real, they won't. Most policies against tobacco and alcohol involves slightly toughening laws in order to inconvenience users. If they wanted to be truly decisive, they would have to ban both. Completely legalizing or just criminalizing every drug would seem like the two default options, legalizing being the most logical, but governments do neither.
To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!